Wednesday, March 11, 2026

This is NOT about “A.I.” or the local film industry.

TL;DR: The Governor’s Office of Economic Opportunity (GOEO) quietly OK’d a $2 million grant for a nonprofit nobody’s heard of. The media made it sound like a done deal, but when I asked GOEO for more information, they told me no decision had been made. Yet, their own public records show that they approved it in January.

When I learned about the approval of a $2 million grant for “Nuovo Film Festival, Inc.,” two things stood out to me:

  1. The lengths to which the GOEO went to hide what they were doing.

  2. The completely redundant goals of the project

When articles started to appear in the local media toward the end of January, most of the attention was focused on “A.I.” hype, which members of the local film community latched onto with understandable frustration. Leaders of existing film-focused nonprofits—myself included—coordinated and reached out to the Nuovo “board” requesting a meeting. As of this post, to my knowledge, nothing has been scheduled.

The way it’s been framed in the press, this $2 million grant looks like a done deal. Some of my colleagues are already trying to make their peace with it. I commented on a post in the Utah Filmmakers™ Facebook group:

“I’m not that worried about it, to be honest. Spending $2 million—even more—on a half-baked concept run by a bunch of amateurs that flops spectacularly upon release happens ALL THE TIME in our industry.”

While most appear to have taken a “wait and see” position, I’ve been trying to find out what’s really going on. When headlines include phrases like “...Initiative gets $2 million from state,” “Utah invests $2 million in an AI-driven film ecosystem,” and “Utah invests $2M in AI cinema,” it creates the impression that this is something that has already happened. These are “news” articles, after all. Of course, headlines are often clickbait—hyperbole and oversimplification to get more ad impressions. Then we read in the articles themselves that the grant has only been “approved” or “...in a standard detail-gathering phase before the grant award is finalized.”

Some articles refer to the GOEO specifically as the agency behind the grant, others treat it as something incidental, as if it may or may not have anything to do with the grant, or as one local writer phrased it, “Working within the context of the Governor’s Office of Economic Opportunity…” (emphasis added, also, F#*%¡&’ really!?!) There are references to “planners,” but no one is identified by name, nor is anyone directly quoted.

As far as I could tell, only one journalist appears to have even made an effort to verify what is still, as far as the press is concerned, just an industry rumor, having reached out to the GOEO and reporting “... board members did not respond to a request for comment.”

I’m not a journalist, but I used to moonlight as a stringer for a rural weekly newspaper, and I’ve acquired a few skills in finding public information for routine due diligence.

While there is nothing on the GOEO’s official website discussing or even referring to a $2 million grant, a diligent search on the Public Notice Website for the state of Utah can yield the following results:

➝ https://www.utah.gov/pmn/

 ↳ https://www.utah.gov/pmn/# (scrolling & clicking of embedded menus)

  ↳ https://www.utah.gov/pmn/sitemap/publicbody/883.html

   ↳ https://www.utah.gov/pmn/sitemap/notice/1058653.html

    ↳ https://www.utah.gov/pmn/files/1389373.docx

“1389373.docx” appears to be an automatically generated filename for the official minutes of the January 8 GOEO Board meeting—posted on February 10 and accompanying the agenda for the following meeting.

This document is the only written confirmation—but confirmation, nevertheless—that the GOEO Board unanimously approved a $2 million grant for “Nuovo Film Festival, Inc.”

Prior to February 10, the only way anyone could have learned about it would have been with a similar search yielding similar results:

➝ https://www.utah.gov/pmn/

 ↳ https://www.utah.gov/pmn/# (scrolling & clicking of embedded menus)

  ↳ https://www.utah.gov/pmn/sitemap/publicbody/883.html

   ↳ https://www.utah.gov/pmn/sitemap/notice/1049891.html

    ↳ https://www.utah.gov/pmn/files/1373837.m4a

“1373837.m4a” is the 50+minute audio recording of the January 8 GOEO Board meeting. The proposal, followed by a unanimous vote of approval, takes up about 12 minutes of the recording, starting around 32 minutes in.

Unlike the other items that were discussed, this was the only item lacking any information of substance on the written agenda—available on the same web page on January 6:

   ↳ https://www.utah.gov/pmn/sitemap/notice/1049891.html

    ↳ https://www.utah.gov/pmn/files/1372663.pdf ⬅︎ (Agenda)

Perhaps none of the Board members felt the need to comment on the news since it’s all there in the official record. Short of a photo-op with a giant novelty check being handed to the grantee, it certainly seems like a done deal.

I wanted a picture of an old man at a desk and this one was free.

Still, I decided to ask for more details about the approval of this grant, since the only publicly available written information amounts to about a page and a half of text. I submitted a formal GRAMA Records Request, which the GOEO’s Records Officer denied, claiming—among other excuses, “...no decision has been made regarding this funding…”

This made no sense to me, so I appealed the denial to GOEO’s Executive Director, who also denied it, adding that the January 8 meeting “...concluded with the Board's recommendation that GOEO support the concept.” A statement that does not square with the verifiable facts in their own official records.

The January 8 agenda said “The Board will vote to approve one IAA grant.” Not a “concept.”

The official minutes of the meeting confirmed what was clearly understood on the audio recording from January 8, that the Board “...recommends Nuovo Film Festival Incorporated (NFI) for an Industrial Assistance Account grant of $2,000,000…” and the motion “...passed with unanimous consent.”

I’ve been told that I have an overdeveloped sense of fairness, and I’ve been known to be trusting of others, to a fault. I will take someone at the word if I haven’t been given a reason not to. So, if I find out someone has lied to me, after the fact, I might be a little more bothered by it than most.

I also have a very low tolerance for people who think they can get away with feeding me an obvious line of bullshit, and God help them if they lie to me when I already know the truth.

For a more in-depth look at all the facts and fibs I’ve been able to find about this matter, check out https://goeo.joepuente.org

Wednesday, February 11, 2026

A need for ethics & transparency

 Please note: The author is not a professional journalist, they just know how to access public information.

On January 8, 2026, the Business Development Board of the Utah Governor’s Office of Economic Opportunity (GOEO) held its monthly meeting in Salt Lake City. The agenda listed three items related to their role in promoting economic growth in Utah. Such items are typically accompanied by detailed information about costs to taxpayers and projected economic benefits, and such was the case for two (2) out of three (3) scheduled items that day. The single exception was an Industrial Assistance Account (IAA) grant with a very short—albeit prescient—description: “The Board will vote to approve one IAA grant.” (emphasis added)

While three motions worth millions of dollars were approved, only two of them were followed by press releases that day. Over the next five days, a total of three local news articles reported on the content of the press releases. It wouldn’t be until January 22—nearly two weeks after the GOEO meeting—that the Utah Review would publish an article by Les Roka about filmmaking in Utah “post-Sundance,” which reported:

“An alternative to establish a film festival to replace Sundance, a new Utah-based nonprofit (tentatively named Nuovo Film Festival, Inc.) has received $2 million funding to launch an initiative that would augment and extend the many components of the state’s filmmaking ecosystem.”

The source of the “$2 million funding” was not entirely clear. The article prominently featured the Utah Film Center, and its founder, Geralyn Dreyfous, quoted multiple times and referenced throughout, including the paragraphs that followed:

“Working within the context of the Governor’s Office of Economic Opportunity, planners have taken into account that the Sundance Institute and its year-round labs… will stay in Utah…Dreyfous explained that the Sundance Lab model would be used to expand filmmaking collaborations in the state with Silicon Slopes, Utah universities, the Nucleus Institute, and other industry partners…”(emphasis added)

“One objective is to cultivate Utah’s leadership in technological innovation in filmmaking, especially as new AI tools come into play. Citing now CGI and VFX technologies gave filmmakers fresh options to integrate them into their creative vision, Dreyfous, acknowledging that her position on AI might not be seen as a popular opinion among her colleagues and peers in the industry, it is important to explore how AI would fit responsibly and ethically in the creative environment.”(sic)

Were it not for that quasi-indirect reference to the GOEO, one might be hard pressed to find a connection between the state agency and a new (“nuovo” in Italian) Utah-based non-profit. The clichéd marketing references to “new AI tools” might even feel like a non-sequiter—unless one happens to have lingering questions about a recent grant that received neither a substantive agenda description nor any public announcement. Especially since the article only stated that the non-profit “received $2 million funding”(sic) and made no reference to what form it took—like a donation or a grant—making it even less likely for a casually informed citizen to know of the existence of any “dots,” to say nothing of having a reason to connect them.

The official minutes of the GOEO’s monthly board meetings are typically posted on the state’s Public Notice website a few days prior to the next meeting. Until then, the only way someone could make a connection between Roka’s article and the GOEO, would be to have listened to the 50+-minute recording of the board meeting itself. It was posted on the same day it took place—where the IAA grant is discussed for nearly twelve minutes. It takes up almost a quarter of the available audio, despite occupying only 2 short lines of text in a seven (7) page agenda.

The disparity between the time spent discussing the grant and the scant information provided to the public is striking. It suggests that, while the board understood the significance of the proposal, they were willing to obscure its true nature and implications, while maintaining a degree of plausible deniability, since all relevant data was, in fact, available to the public. It just happened to be in a format that was not readily searchable, with a nondescript filename (“1373837.m4a”), and required anyone wanting to access that specific data to download a digital audio file and play it. Thankfully, technology has progressed to the point where all those technical steps can take place in a new browser tab—but it still requires clicking the link, sitting still for nearly an hour, and listening. Most people won’t do that, but this writer will, and they have.

Around 32-minutes into the recording, it’s revealed that the grant in question was a one-time $2 million IAA award for an entity called “Nuovo Film Festival Inc.” (NFFI), pitched as a bold response to the departure of the Sundance Film Festival from Utah and an ambitious attempt to reassert the state’s place in the global film industry.

The pitch for NFFI leans heavily on marketing clichés and technology buzzwords. The objectives of this organization are described as a “forward-thinking approach” that will “keep Utah relevant in the film space,” “build on Utah’s legacy while embracing where the industry is going,” and “position Utah as the center of next-generation storytelling through AI-enabled filmmaking labs and the nation’s first AI-supported soundstage.”

Throughout the presentation, “AI” is invoked with the enthusiasm of a recent retiree trying desperately to sound hip to the younger generation, blissfully unaware of how all the fancy high-tech jargon he’s reciting falls flat and would fail to impress anyone who actually knew something about concepts like “vaporware” or remembers when the “dot-com” bubble burst in the early 2000s. If any of those people were in attendance at that meeting, they didn’t say anything.

They went on to claim Utah will “not only stay on the map, but lead in the emerging world of AI-driven film and content creation,” promising a transformation in production timelines and costs that would purportedly allow an $200 Million “Avenger” film to be made in nine months for $10 million—a statement that bears little resemblance to the economic realities of modern film production.

At the same time, the proposal repeatedly frames itself as “establishing an ecosystem” for filmmaking in Utah, as if such an ecosystem doesn’t already exist. In reality, Utah already has a robust film infrastructure and a dedicated state agency, the Utah Film Commission, whose mission is to promote the state as a destination for film production, administer incentives, and support local and visiting filmmakers. The Commission even registered the trademark, “Utah. America’s Film Set.®” The rhetoric around creating labs, boosting incentives, workforce training, and film tourism largely repackages work that existing organizations and vendors have been doing for years. The notion that Utah needs a new entity to “put Utah on the map” for filmmaking ignores a century of filmmaking history in Utah, the Film Commission’s ongoing efforts, and the undeniable success of the state’s Motion Picture Incentive programs.

The funding source for this grant makes the situation more troubling. During the meeting, a board member notes that the $2 million in question had been “previously allocated to Sundance” and that, with Sundance leaving Utah, the money had “come back.” This characterization glosses over the specific conditions the Utah Legislature attached to that funding. In S.B. 2, the New Fiscal Year Supplemental Appropriations Act for 2025, lawmakers earmarked $3.5 million for the Sundance Institute, but only on the condition that Sundance remained in Utah. The bill language explicitly states that GOEO “shall not disburse the funds provided for this purpose and shall allow them to lapse” if Sundance chooses to leave the state. In other words, the legislature did not authorize GOEO to repurpose those funds at its discretion. Once Sundance announced its move to Colorado and confirmed that its future festivals would no longer be hosted in Utah, the statute required that the appropriation lapse rather than be redirected.

By approving a $2 million grant that proponents themselves describe as using money previously allocated for Sundance, the GOEO board appears to have disregarded this legislative directive. Describing the funds as having “come back” implies a return of money that had gone out the door, when in reality the funds were contingent and never meant to be spent if Sundance left. The decision to treat those contingent dollars as a discretionary pool for a new project contradicts the statute’s clear intent and undermines the principle that executive agencies must follow the conditions set by the legislature. This is not a mere technical oversight; it is a substantive deviation from the rules governing the use of public money.

Compounding these concerns is the process’s opacity and the confusion surrounding the nonprofit entity that is supposed to receive and manage the funds. In the meeting, a representative claimed that the grant would be administered by a nonprofit organization with a board that includes high-profile industry figures and local leaders—of the six named individuals, only two had any notable connection to the entertainment industry.

A query using the IRS Tax Exempt Organization Search Tool “did not return any results” for “Nuovo Film Festival, Inc.” Tax Exempt status is typically a requirement for nonprofit grant recipients, but Industrial Assistance Accounts may also be awarded to for-profit companies. Similar queries on transparency websites, including CharityCheck101.org and Candid.org, yielded similar results, but they will list nonprofits with or without a tax-exempt classification simply to confirm that they exist based on their federal Employer Identification Number (EIN)—which is also required for a business or charity to open a bank account, especially if one expects to receive any donations or grants.

An argument could be made that a nonprofit organization formed within the preceding year may still be in the process of obtaining its Tax Exempt Determination letter. However, it did not take long to find several examples of Utah nonprofit organizations registered in 2025 that have already obtained tax-exempt status. One of the most recent was formed in December, just over two months before this post was published.

The author concedes that an EIN may have been issued to Nuovo Film Festival, Inc., and that they have simply done nothing with it to warrant inclusion in any public databases. Regardless, if any entity that stands to receive a multi-million-dollar public grant is not properly established or its governance is unclear, it raises serious questions about due diligence and risk management.

All of this returns us to the core issue: transparency and ethics in the management of public funds. A $2 million grant is not a routine matter, and describing it on the agenda simply as “one IAA grant,” accompanied by the prescriptive, “The Board will vote to approve one IAA grant,” when a description would have been apropos, fails to meet even minimal standards of public disclosure. Omitting a press release for such a significant award, especially when other, smaller items receive public promotion, suggests an awareness that the decision might not withstand scrutiny. When an agency uses vague, bureaucratic language to obscure the nature of its actions—particularly when those actions appear to conflict with specific legislative instructions—it erodes public trust and undermines democratic oversight.

Transparent governance entails more than technical compliance with open meeting requirements; it demands clear, accurate, and forthright communication about how taxpayer dollars are being used and why certain entities are chosen as beneficiaries. It requires agencies to respect not only the letter of appropriations law but also the intent behind conditional funding and lapse provisions. In this case, the combination of buzzword-heavy justification, repackaging existing film infrastructure as novel innovation, questionable reuse of contingent legislative funds, and the absence of robust public communication points to a failure to fulfill that responsibility. The public has a right to expect that decisions about multi-million-dollar grants will be made openly, with full and honest disclosure—not hidden in plain sight behind innocuous boilerplate and evasive phrasing.

Current Revision: February 13, 2026

(Grammar corrections and language clarifications)

Wednesday, February 12, 2025

One cent distraction

I’ve been distracted by the social media chaos caused by the flood of executive orders coming out of D.C. despite the fact that I’m aware that distraction and chaos are not bugs in the program; they’re part of the design.

One of those distractions was the President’s “order”* to cease minting the penny, which costs around 300% of its face value to produce. Supporters and opponents of the president are arguing for and against this action. While it might appear to make sense (no pun intended) at a superficial level, within the context of the administration’s tidal wave of orders, memos, and notices, this one seemingly innocuous—and unoriginal—idea is serving its intended purpose: not to affect actual change (again, no pun intended), but to serve as just another distraction. The more people are regurgitating arguments for and against abolishing the one-cent coin, the less they’re talking about the erosion of civil rights, wealth inequality, and an actual constitutional crisis that may be unfolding before our eyes.

This is not about any one Executive Order. It’s about the blatant disregard for the separation of powers—not just by the President, but those in his party ostensibly in control of the House and Senate. Congress has the prerogative of delegating authority to the Executive branch through legislation. When the President starts taking actions that extend beyond that authority, we have a problem. When Congress is made aware of it and consciously chooses to do nothing, essentially ceding its authority to the President through inaction—some might call it a dereliction of duty—it’s up to the courts to reign in the administration. Unfortunately, the Constitution doesn’t quite explain what to do when the President ignores the other branches of the government.

Some will still argue that the President shouldn’t have to follow every single law, especially concerning little things like the material cost of striking a penny. “We can make an exception for that, right?” they’ll ask.

Let’s consider just one possible outcome of normalizing a selective disregard for the Constitutional framework that’s been in place since 1789. If we, the people—be it through Congress or the courts—say, “The President can ignore the law concerning the penny,” what’s to stop him from using it as a tacit endorsement to ignore the law wherever and whenever he wants?

When we, the people, see what he’s doing and then complain about it, his defense will most likely consist of throwing the people’s own words back at us:

“You said, ‘The President can ignore the law…’”

The rest of the original sentence's context doesn’t matter to him. It never did, and it never will. I’m willing to bet all the pennies on that.

Tuesday, May 21, 2024

On the aftermath of a closed matter

The few years leading up to 2024 were difficult for me. the challenges I faced during this period crystallized around an incident that occurred in early 2023. While I have written about it before—mostly through company memoranda as the events unfolded—my focus in those memos was placed squarely on the facts of the matter, with somewhat incidental references to how I was personally affected by it. As I reflect on the experience over a year later, I do so with a closer examination of the resulting emotional and psychological trauma I experienced. I want to assure the reader that I’m not being hyperbolic. I was traumatized.

The incident involved someone I considered a friend and colleague for over a decade. For several years, they volunteered in public-facing capacities and positions of trust with my non-profit organization, which has served the local film community for over twenty years.

Hoping to build upon that professional relationship, toward the end of 2022, I submitted to them an in-kind sponsorship proposal that I had been developing for over a year. It would have involved my nonprofit organization and a recurring local event. The idea was mutually beneficial but was conceived to work primarily for their benefit. Since it was just a proposal, there was nothing legally binding and plenty of room for discussing alternative approaches and paths moving forward. Its in-kind nature—i.e., there was no requirement for money to change hands—was a defining characteristic, despite having made a considerable investment of time and personal financial resources to make it possible, including acquiring some intellectual and digital assets that were integral to the proposal. 

It was written in plain language with basic business terms. After the proposal was submitted, they suddenly became very quiet. Every time I tried to follow up, I was given excuses and false assurances for why they were not talking. This lack of communication severely aggravated my struggles with general anxiety disorder.

They finally agreed to a conference call to discuss the proposal in more detail—or so I thought. That was when I learned that a grudge was being held against me over something that had occurred several years before but was not brought to my attention until that meeting, during which I was berated, ridiculed, and verbally assaulted to the point that I needed to be excused because the experience triggered in me an intense panic attack.

Their unwillingness to communicate with me about the in-kind sponsorship, their grudge—held in secret and festering for years—and their general lack of decorum in what was ostensibly a business meeting informed my decision to withdraw the proposal.

In an attempt to salvage at least a working relationship, I decided to donate the aforementioned assets to them, asking for nothing in return. They accepted the donation and then extended an invitation to discuss my plans for my nonprofit in the new year. This put me somewhat at ease as far as future cooperation was concerned. I happened to be working on a draft of a new strategic plan for the organization and shared a confidential, watermarked copy with them before our subsequent conversation.

Only after that discussion did I learn of actions they had secretly taken during the preceding weeks. After I had submitted my proposal a month prior, the first thing they did was to register a new business entity with a name described in legal terms regarding intellectual property as “confusingly similar” to that of my nonprofit organization—a name that is registered as a trademark in the state of Utah. They also registered multiple internet domain names and set up several social media profiles using the same confusingly similar moniker, also in complete secrecy, going so far as to preemptively block my primary social media profile in an apparent attempt to hide them from me. The only purpose that these actions appeared to serve was in preparation for an effort to supplant or otherwise undermine my nonprofit organization, its mission, and its role in the community.

I was devastated to learn this—especially after I had trusted them with my draft strategic plan, elements of which they later plagiarized elsewhere on social media—again, the document was watermarked and explicitly labeled “Confidential” on every page. I emailed them, reminding them of my efforts to be completely transparent in all my interactions with them and that I expected them to extend to me that same courtesy. Instead, they chose to be deceptive and disingenuous, to exploit their access to me and my trust in them. Then, they chose to ignore me.

This resulted in a follow-up meeting to specifically discuss how their actions demonstrated a conflict of interest regarding their roles with my nonprofit and how they violated multiple clauses in the organization’s Code of Ethics & Conduct. Yet, in the face of evidence to the contrary, they denied having any knowledge or culpability.

I fired them from their volunteer duties on the advice of legal counsel. Despite that, they were still considered members of the organization at the community level and were invited to continue to use the same resources available to all community-tier members, including our Facebook group—the official forum of the organization. Additionally, I was willing to keep the entire matter confidential—I’m not in the habit of punching down when somebody makes a mistake, especially one with the potential to cause severe embarrassment, were it to become public knowledge. Despite the invitation to stay without restrictions, they left the Facebook group.

I was heartbroken by this experience, but it only got worse.

It was not long before they stated their intention to pursue a venture that would reclassify their problematic behavior from simply unethical to overtly illegal. I felt that the potential consequences for such actions were severe enough that they needed to be brought to their attention through a third party.

They were informed of the possible legal and financial ramifications of following through on their stated plans in addition to the actions they had already taken, implored to abandon their project, and—for the sake of their reputations in the local film community—were still offered the opportunity to keep the matter confidential.

They consciously chose to forfeit a profoundly generous offer to keep their unethical and illegal actions from becoming public knowledge by making a public social media post. However, instead of addressing the actual problems communicated to them, they deliberately misrepresented the matter to damage my personal and professional reputation. They made blatantly false statements about me, and when pressed for details, they withheld relevant information that would contradict their previous statements—and undermine the narrative that began to form with the speculative comments of others. They made additional misleading and false assertions and reinforced speculation that they knew for a fact was inaccurate.

Their public post made me the target of online harassment through private messages, hurtful comments on my personal social media profile, and even through a post in the Facebook group I admin—which has an unambiguous rule against bullying and harassment.

Those who said disparaging things about me, angered by the lies they read, included people that I thought were my friends. Filmmakers I had worked with. Artists that I had HIRED! Some unfriended me without notice. Others just stopped communicating with me altogether. The emotional toll this took on me was intense and painful, and I can count on one hand the number of people who contacted me directly to let me know that they supported me and could see right through the negative things that were being said. Only a few others asked me if there was any validity to the claims.

The emotional trauma triggered in me thoughts of committing suicide and led to my hospitalization for several days with severe depression—a fact that, until now, I had only shared with a handful of close friends.

Eventually, the artificially induced outrage subsided. Since the former volunteer rendered moot the offer of confidentiality, several people who had engaged with the disparaging post were contacted privately and presented with the facts of the matter in their entirety. Some of them chose to ignore the truth. Others who had expressed anger at the lies they were told had a change of heart once they had all the relevant information and apologized to me personally. What I found most frustrating was that so many people were willing just to take the lies at face value. Nothing prevented them from reaching out to me to ask me directly if anything that had been said was true. Despite being given accurate information that disproved what they had been told on the matter, I guess it was easier to embrace the lies and unchecked speculation they were subjected to than to try to ask questions for which there were answers.

Throughout that experience, I shared some personal observations and discussed my emotional pain on social media in posts that were accessible only to a few close friends, all without making any specific references. There was some brief discussion in the Facebook group—ironically, in the comments section of the post that was attacking me. Eventually, one of the other moderators removed the post.

I spent the better part of the next year processing what had happened. I was already feeling isolated, but I became genuinely fearful of going out in public, especially to any community film events. As I’ve tried to contact people to discuss matters related to the nonprofit—program involvement, following up on previous correspondence, etc.—I’ve received responses that were polite but would say something to the effect of no longer wanting to be a member, or asking to be “unsubscribed.” Every time, I would be left dumbfounded, sending me down a rabbit hole of speculation, anxiety, and self-doubt, asking myself, “Did someone say something to them that was disparaging of me or the organization? Are people still talking about the lies as if they actually happened? If that’s the case, why didn’t they just say something directly to me in their response?”

Bad-faith actors bring existing problems into greater focus

As painful and discouraging as the experience was, it was also par for the course regarding the kinds of problems in the local film community that are actively—if not intentionally—putting the local film industry at a disadvantage. I’ve always been aware of these problems, but instead of calling them out publicly over the years, I chose to err on the side of highlighting what’s being done right to help the local industry grow, but these problems can’t be solved unless we’re willing to talk about them openly.

Throughout the following year, I wrote extensively about these problems on my nonprofit’s official blog, describing behaviors and attitudes I’ve observed that are, at best, unprofessional and, at worst, unethical or illegal. I started with an essay about values and ethics, specifically, the organization’s Core Values of Professionalism, Integrity, and Respect and its Code of Ethics & Conduct. Each text is largely identical, with the former presented in the abstract and the latter as a standard to strive for and uphold. The composition of these documents specifically addresses some unprofessional practices that have become so prevalent that aspiring filmmakers are emulating them because they’ve been misled to believe that’s how things have always been done—or worse, how they’re supposed to be done.

When discussing examples of problematic behaviors in our online forum—always in general terms because one of the rules is “Talk about problems and solutions, not people”—a member once commented, “I think I know who you might be referring to.”

My immediate response was, essentially, “I’m not talking about an individual person. These are problems that I’ve observed over many years from several people across several productions.” Local filmmakers who cut corners on productions—even contracted work from which they personally profit—and wannabe auteurs putting on airs, embellishing the breadth of their knowledge, their connections, and their abilities, to get movies made that are mediocre, at best, but ultimately unsaleable.

Although names are not mentioned, it’s not unheard of for individuals who recognize themselves in the actions being described to angrily protest being unfairly criticized—outing themselves in the process. This anger—rooted in embarrassment and rightfully so—is often directed at me, as is the blame for inciting it. Of course, the only person who can honestly be held responsible for one’s emotions is the one experiencing them.

In reality, most of them aren’t embarrassed simply because they have fine-tuned the image they present to others for so long that they have come to believe it themselves. If only a few of them ever came to realize that what they call their “careers” are little more than long cons that actually damage the local industry and cause quantifiable socio-economic harm to the community, maybe they’d own up to it, and either figure out how to do it right or just find another line of work.

Unfortunately, most of them have reached a point of no return from which their egos will not allow them to retreat. They’re usually too distracted by having moved onto their “next big project” to consider, or even acknowledge, that everything else they’ve made up to that point probably isn’t worth much more than the cost of maintaining their entries on the IMDb—which they don’t even have to pay for.

Like any other community filmmaker, I’ve always dreamed of becoming a film industry professional. I don’t recall exactly when or where I read the following advice, but it was something to the effect of:

“The best way to achieve your dreams is by helping others to achieve theirs.”

That resonated with me, and I immediately applied it to any project I was asked to participate in—going the extra mile to help make those productions the best they could be within the scope of my contributions. It also sharpened the focus of my nonprofit’s mission. The dream is often boiled down to just wanting to be able to make movies, but there’s more to it than that. It’s to be able to make movies for a living.

As I learned more about industry standards, pitfalls to avoid, and local resources that can genuinely help people become industry professionals, I did not keep that information to myself; I shared it in blog posts and on social media—typically in my nonprofit’s official forum—in comment sections, direct messages, and in person. The most valuable lessons learned are most often the result of recognizing mistakes that have been made. I also ask the full-time professional filmmakers among our members to share their experiences—especially their mistakes—and talk about what they learned.

Of course, there have been times when I would share some insights from a painfully learned experience, and someone would accuse me of being a “know-it-all.” A taunt that is as childish and immature as it sounds.

Having a basic grasp of the technical steps of making a film is not enough to make a living as a filmmaker. Even more than practical experience, it requires understanding and accepting that the craft’s business aspect is essential to filmmaking and inextricable. That’s why the film industry exists, and if one seriously wants to be part of any industry, one needs to learn, embrace, and work within its established standards. Yet, I also get pushback from people who are making a living at what they do.

In addition to being called a “know-it-all,” I’ve also been accused of “gatekeeping;” defined as: “When someone takes it upon themselves to decide who does or does not have access or rights to a community or identity.” It might also be a dig at me for being an admin for an online forum because I have the ability to kick people out. Of course, our continually growing membership numbers support the notion that it’s an inclusive and welcoming community… or I’m just not a very good gatekeeper.

I’ve come to embrace a broad and inclusive definition of filmmaker. Anyone who uses any of the tools of filmmaking to create a motion picture—regardless of its budget, duration, or how it’s viewed—can consider themselves a filmmaker, and I’m happy to refer to them as such. However, being a filmmaker is NOT the same as working in the film industry.

As someone who only moonlights in the film industry, I’ll be the first to acknowledge that I’m not in a position to offer anyone tailored career advice, to say nothing of presuming to be able to control anyone’s access to something as abstract as a “community or identity.” Nobody has that power, but some people think they do. I strive to share factual information from reputable film industry sources and my personal observations.

I’ve come to understand that a person who’s quick to accuse someone of “gatekeeping” usually doesn’t like to be told things they don’t want to hear. For example—an extremely basic one—it’s generally understood within the film industry that producing a film is a business venture. The point of investing in any business is to see a return on that investment, which is true in all industries.

Still, some filmmakers insist on pushing back on that, saying things like, “It doesn’t have to be a business venture!” Or they’ll say something like, “I’m not in it for the money,”—which would be fine if they’re already making a living as industry filmmakers, but such responses come more often from community filmmakers—in other words, locals who struggle to make a living as filmmakers. They often have to work a day job in a different industry, and they resent it. They try to make their films on the weekends, convincing themselves that they “care more about the art” despite wanting desperately to get a job doing what they love instead of what’s actually paying their bills.

The painful truth is that, consciously or not, “I’m not in it for the money” is usually a code phrase that means, “I don’t know how to make money doing this,” and anyone who reminds them of that frustrating reality gets labeled a “gatekeeper,” becoming a convenient target to blame for their perceived career failure instead of owning their unwillingness to learn industry standards—or unlearn what’s actually holding them back.

Many amateur filmmakers in Utah have convinced themselves that the business aspects of filmmaking are optional or can be circumstantially redefined for the sake of their “art.” These “faux-professionals” do make movies; some are quite prolific at it, so much so that they actually believe they work in the film industry and will say that they do—especially to aspirational filmmakers looking to “get their foot in the door,” but wind up just “paying their dues” by “volunteering” because they’ve been invited to be on what they’ve been told is a “real” film set.

What “industry” are we talking about exactly?

There exists, in Utah, a thriving video production industry. Much commercial and corporate production has fueled the growth of our local filmmaking infrastructure. As the tools of professional videography have become more advanced and less expensive over the last quarter of a century, the technological lines between producing narrative motion pictures and commercial niches like corporate training videos have blurred considerably. Professional videographers, whether they’re shooting weddings, the local news, or producing product demonstration videos, can call themselves filmmakers as much as anyone on the set of a feature film bound for theatrical release or a limited series for a streaming service. Still, even though technology has increased the amount of overlap between the two, the video production and film industries remain as distinct from each other as the concepts of industry and community. This is no secret to those who make an honest living within any industry, and it brings up another problematic archetype that’s poisoning the well of local talent. Unlike the “faux-professionals” referenced above, “working amateurs” do, in fact, make their living as filmmakers. Unfortunately, in addition to conflating the industry in which they work with one in which they might participate occasionally, their understanding of the word “professionalism” is limited to “being paid” for what they do.

It’s been my observation that such a myopic understanding of what it means to be a “professional” often goes hand in hand with arrogant attitudes, condescending, and/or manipulative behavior toward those perceived to have less experience or who have simply embraced a more comprehensive definition of the term and interpretation of how it may be applied.

As I shared in an Instagram post:

Still, it’s an attitude that seems practically engrained in the local community culture. Based on my experience, having been on the receiving end of this behavior from so-called “professionals” for years, this is what real “gatekeeping” looks like. It’s not just uninformed value judgments; it’s personal insults and attacks—also uninformed, delivered strategically, and with malice—that appear to serve only one purpose: to keep their targets out of “the industry” by undermining their self-esteem and sabotaging their confidence in their own knowledge and talents. The easiest way to keep them from getting their proverbial foot in the door is to try and get them to give up on looking for it.

“Faux-professional” and “working-amateur” filmmakers create problems for themselves, the “proteges” they entice into doing their bidding for “experience” and for the local film industry as a whole. Especially when they manage to talk their way into a paying gig on a legitimate film industry production. They are the reason that “Utah filmmakers” have a “reputation” for being “arrogant,” “entitled,” “unprofessional,” and “difficult to work with.” Ironically, they also complain the most about out-of-state productions that come to Utah for the Motion Picture Incentive and then bring in crew members from out of state instead of hiring locals. What they perceive as “cronyism” or “nepotism” is—in reality—an example of how a professional film production would rather settle for a lower rebate on their in-state spending if it means they don’t have to deal with a local grip, AC, or PA who thinks they’re the next Stanley Kubrick and won’t shut up about it and just do the job they’re being paid for.

Many local professionals are more than capable of working in those positions with gratitude and a demonstrable comprehension of what professionalism actually means. Most of them are getting hired onto productions every year and truly making their livings working in Utah’s film industry. Still, it’s amateurs with a “fake-it-’til-you-make-it” attitude, talking their way onto those sets, revealing their own incompetence, and are too arrogant to recognize that they, themselves, are the ones screwing up opportunities for local professionals who actually know what they’re doing. The next thing you know, we’ve got knowledgeable, talented production personnel opting to relocate to Los Angeles, New Mexico, or Georgia because they can’t get hired as “Utah filmmakers.”

I want the term “Utah filmmaker” to inspire confidence, not to be a red flag. Especially when it comes to incentivized productions that need to hire local cast and crew.

(Updated: September 5, 2024)